RE: [WW] Class Balance

[Wes Anderson <wes.anderson@lucasfilm.com>]

Clearly you are not playing the game in true military fashion.

Here is how my game goes, as I am the scout and not the officer.

Officer: Private, Recon that hedge over there while I stand back here behind
this tree with the medic.
Scout: Yes, Sir.

GM: Make a hide roll.
Scout: I got a 27
GM: A barrage of gunfire comes from the hedge. You take 47 points.

Me: Damn, time to roll up another Scout.

Wes

-----Original Message-----
From: Casey McGirt [mailto:cmcgirt@hotmail.com] 
Sent: Saturday, August 11, 2001 11:05 PM
To: weirdwars@gamerz.net
Subject: [WW] Class Balance


Overall, I really like the Weird Wars rules.  But I'm a little worried about

class balance - some of the classes are a lot more powerful than others.

Case in point...the Scout.  I went and compared him to the Officer, and the 
comparison doesn't even come close:
* Scout - d8 hit dice, best attack progression, good Fort save, 4 skill 
points/level, bonus Feat every 3 levels, Sneak Attack, Track, Pathfinder, 
Uncanny Dodge, One With Nature.
* Officer - d8 hit dice, best attack progression, good Will save, fair Fort 
save, 4 skill points/level, bonus feat every 3 levels, Rank.

I'm having a little trouble seeing how Rank and a slight save boost stack up

against Sneak Attack, Track, Pathfinder, Uncanny Dodge, and One With Nature.

  Unless I'm missing something, the Officer seems to get the short end of 
the stick (even with the ability to be in charge).

Likewise, the medic seems to be a bit of a lightweight.  The chart shows two

bonus feats (total), Unflappable, and Improved Healing.  They get a lower 
attack bonus than any of the other military classes (not counting prestige 
classes, of course), a lower HD than the grunt, and the same amount of 
skills.  Their main advantage is the ability to avoid some (but not all) 
enemy fire, due to the Geneva Conventions (something the horrors of the 
Weird Wars aren't likely to care about).  At the least, I would have 
expected more skill points or a few extra special abilities.  The only thing

that balances out the medic is the "cleric syndrome" - someone needs to play

the healer if you want the group to survive.

I'm trying to figure out what to do when I run the game.  I have a few ideas

to balance the classes out (some roleplaying adjustments, and some changes 
in the mechanics), but I was wondering if anyone else sees the same problems

I do.

-Casey

_________________________________________________________________
Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com/intl.asp


To unsubscribe, send a message to esquire@gamerz.net with
	unsubscribe weirdwars
as the BODY of the message.  The SUBJECT is ignored.